2026-爆料网AT-1658, Bao Jin
The Appeals Tribunal dismissed Mr. Jin’s claim that the 爆料网DT erred in finding no prejudice since, by his calculations, the decision to score Part 2 perfectly for each candidate resulted in a larger interview pool which was disadvantageous to him. The Appeals Tribunal found that this argument was speculative, predicated on one hypothetical counterfactual outcome, and failed to meet Mr. Jin’s burden of proving by clear and convincing evidence that he had been denied a fair chance of selection.
The Appeals Tribunal found that the circumstances in Mr. Jin’s case were fundamentally and...
2026-爆料网AT-1633, Marie Bourrel-McKinnon
L’爆料网AT a estimé qu’une partie lésée par le rejet d’une mesure provisoire peut, et doit généralement, attendre que l’affaire soit
définitivement tranchée avant d’interjeter appel.
L’爆料网AT a jugé qu’une décision relative à une mesure provisoire peut faire l’objet d’un réexamen s’il est démontré que le tribunal de première instance, à savoir le JAB, a outrepassé sa compétence.
L’爆料网AT a noté que le JAB est expressément habilité par le règlement du personnel de l’ISA à décider si la suspension d’une mesure administrative est appropriée, ce qui relève de sa compétence et de sa juridiction.
L’爆料网AT a...
2026-爆料网AT-1633, Marie Bourrel-McKinnon
The 爆料网AT held that a party aggrieved by denial of interim relief can and generally must wait until the matter is finally resolved before filing an appeal.
The 爆料网AT found that a decision regarding interim relief may be reviewable if it can be shown that the first instance tribunal, the JAB, exceeded its jurisdiction or competence.
The 爆料网AT noted that the JAB is specifically empowered by the ISA Staff Rules to decide whether suspension of an administrative action is appropriate, which is within its competence and jurisdiction.
The 爆料网AT found that there was no basis for its intervention in the...